The Velvet Café

A room for thoughts about movies

German, female and silent – a different take on Hamlet

with 4 comments

Did you know that Hamlet in fact was a woman in disguise? The only reason that she was dressed like a guy was that her mother was taking measures to secure the succession of the throne. At least if we’re to believe a certain Dr Edward P Vining who in 1881 published the book “The Mystery of Hamlet”, where he presented his ideas.

This book is the source of inspiration for what probably is the oddest version of Hamlet I’ve seen in my entire life. Not only is Hamlet played by a woman (a Danish actress named Asta Nielsen, who was one of the first international movie stars). Hamlet is also German and doesn’t say a word since it’s a silent film.

As I’ve mentioned earlier, I’m happy to have a film club in my city, which not only has access to an old fashioned, gently renovated theatre; they also show silent movies once in a while with live music to go with it. In a world of conformity, worldwide releases and box office records, it offers something different – the flavor of experiencing something exclusive, something not everyone else has access to or is able to enjoy.

You’re like people who frown at bag-in-box wine, importing their bottles directly from a special castle no one else has heard of. You’re like someone who won’t eat a bar of chocolate with less than that the cacao beans have a sort name and specified origin. It’s the very opposite of mass consumption.

Not taking this aspect into account, just looking at the film as such, I have to admit that it ended up with an average rating. For sure it’s interesting to watch the androgenic Asta Nielsen and the music was beautifully performed. But my interest dropped as time went by and the uncomfortable (though historically correct) seats started to have an impact on my bum. One hour would have been fine. Two hours and 13 minutes was a little too much of the goodness, regardless of how different it was to the films I usually watch.

Perhaps there is a truth in what the silent film fans who recently were guests at Ryan McNeil’s podcast In Between Days. Their recommendation for a beginner of silent film watching was to leave out the drama and go for the comedies, since they’re way more accessible. A 2 hour + Hamlet adaption might be something that mostly speaks to the more experienced hardcore fans.

My greatest enjoyment of the night turned out to be a short bonus film, The Film Primadonna. This film, or should I rather say fragment, consists of the 250 or so remaining meters of what once had been a full length feature film. The other 1500 meters have been lost on the way. Like Hamlet this film also stars Asta Nielsen, but here she plays a contemporary film star. So essentially this is a film about film making in 1913, and that’s what made it so interesting. You can read and learn every so much about the childhood of the movies or you can watch Hugo for that sake, but it feels more real when you watch a film set through the eyes of another film maker from a century ago.

Hamlet (Sven Gade, GE, 1921) My rating: 3/5

The Film Primadonna (Die Filmprimadonna, Urban Gad, GE, 1913) My rating: 4/5

Written by Jessica

March 29, 2012 at 1:00 am

4 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. ….I may or may not end up muting silent films and end up playing over wildly imappropriate soundtracks.

    Phantom of the opera for Charlie Chaplin? check.

    J-pop for that french romance? check.

    I’d probably have to do like Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles for very odd Hamlet.

    …also I’m sorry but Patrick Stewart will always be the only Hamlet for me *nerdswoon*

    Holly "Digit" Dotson

    March 29, 2012 at 5:21 am

    • The thought has striked me how much the score means for how you perceive the silent film. It definitely could spice up a silent film that feels a tad too long, like Hamlet.

      And ❤ Patrick Stewart!


      March 29, 2012 at 9:28 am

  2. […] Name: Online-Inquirer Fantasia Submitted by: Online-Inquirer Site Name: The Velvet Café German, female and silent – a different take on Hamlet Submitted by: The Velvet Café Site Name: Banana Oil Science (vs.) Fiction? Submitted by: Banana […]

  3. […] Name: Online-Inquirer Fantasia Submitted by: Online-Inquirer Site Name: The Velvet Café German, female and silent – a different take on Hamlet Submitted by: The Velvet Café Site Name: Banana Oil Science (vs.) Fiction? Submitted by: Banana […]

Leave a Reply to The Large Association of Movie Blogs | Classic Chops: April 4th Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: