The Velvet Café

A room for thoughts about movies

A brave movie from the country where they put filmmakers in jail

with 17 comments

“How well will my movie make in the box office? Will it be enough for them to trust me to make another film?”

I imagine thoughts like this pop up in the mind of a film maker every now and then. Or, for the ones who are more artsy than market oriented:

“Will I get approval by the critic NN? Will it make a success at the festival circuit? Will my peers respect me?”

But there are places in the world where the questions are about something completely different:

“Will I get away with this? Will they allow it at all? Could I end up in a prison? Or if not – did I compromise too much, censoring myself?”

Filmmakers in prison
I thought about this as I watched the recent movie A Separation, which is made by the Iranian director Asghar Farhadi.

I don’t know what worries he’s been up to making the film, but I would be surprised if the process has been pain free. After all he lives in a country where movies are rigorously examined by authorities and you need a special beforehand permission for every piece of music you want to use.

Some Iranian filmmakers have fled the country. Others have been arrested, such as Jafar Panahi, who now is serving a six year prison punishment for daring to make movies that challenge the regime. He is forbidden to make any more movies, give any further interviews or to leave Iran for the next 20 years.

I don’t know how Fahadi got his film through the system, but I wonder what the Iranian government now makes of his success. A Separation has been widely praised by critics and was awarded at the Berlin festival earlier this year.

Are they proud and see it as a chance to give Iran some positive press? Or are they worried because it draws the attention of the world audience to the oppression and the poor circumstances that many people – particularly women – live under in Iran? If I were in their position I would be worried.

A political movie
At first sight A Separation doesn’t carry any political message. It begins as a story about a middle class couple in Iran that is going through a divorce. Simin, the woman, wants to leave the country. Nader refuses to do so since he wants to take care of his senile father who lives with them. And in the middle is their daughter who has ties to both parents and would rather not have to choose between them.

Nader hires a woman, Razieh, to help him to look after his father while he’s at work. One day something happens and Nader finds himself accused of having pushed Razieh to fall in the stairs in such a way that she had a miscarriage. Soon enough they’re in court, and that’s what most of the movie is about. It’s a court drama, alternated with images from the growing conflict between the two families involved.

I guess the political dimension isn’t too obvious (far from all reviews I’ve seen of the movie has even mentioned it), and perhaps that’s why it also has slipped under the radar of the authorities in Iran.

You could argue that it’s a movie about personal choices about individuals handling ethical dilemmas, universal issues of right and wrong that aren’t tied to a certain confession or ideology.

But for me it was most of all a reminder about how harsh it must be to live in Iran if you’re a secularized intellectual with a modern perspective on life.

Several critics have mentioned how it brings an updated image of how the middleclass live their lives in Iran of today. In some ways their lifestyle resembles a lot to the lifestyle of middleclass people anywhere in the world. They too are trying to bring their life puzzle together. They too heat their dinner in a microwave oven.

But it also shows something more. It shows a view on women that we left behind us hundreds if not thousands of years ago that is still in action. It shows laws that don’t make a lot of sense and an arbitrary court system. It shows a land ruled by rigorous religious beliefs, where human rights are put aside in the name of God.

Divorcing a country
I must admit to begin with I couldn’t quite understand why Simin insisted on having this divorce, why she was so desperate to leave Iran that she was ready to sacrifice her marriage and perhaps even the relationship to her daughter for it. It seemed a bit coldhearted and unreasonable, even selfish. But as the movie went by I changed as I started to see Iran through her eyes. I understood why she had to go, even if it was a decision that would give her pain. She wanted more out of life than she could get if she stayed, like so many other non religious Iranians who have seen no alternative but to choose the exile. We’re not just watching the he separation between a man and a woman; we’re also watching the separation from a country.

A few days have passed since I watched A Separation, but it keeps lingering in my mind, especially in the light of the destiny of Jafar Panahi. I had never heard of him before, but I learned about his case as I was doing a little research for this post.

Of course I’ve not been unaware of that there are countries where the right to free speech isn’t respected. However it isn’t something I usually pay a lot of thoughts, busy as I am with my own life. Aren’t we all? But the story about the filmmaker put in jail managed to break through my natural defense system against “misery of the world news”. I get equally angry and sad when I think about it.

As for the movie my biggest concerns are with the teenage daughter of Nader and Simin. Will she ever get to live in a country where she’s allowed to let her hair fly freely in the air? Where she can make the movie she wants to and use any music she likes without asking for permission?

There is no answer. But I know what I hope for.

A Separation (Jodaeiye Nader az Simin, Asghar Farhadi, IR, 2011) My rating: 4/5

Written by Jessica

November 14, 2011 at 1:00 am

Posted in A Separation

17 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Is there an explanation for why Nader cannot bring with his father?

    It’s so pitiful to see ideologies that fear dissent. Do they recognize that their views and actions would not hold up under scrutiny?


    November 14, 2011 at 4:14 am

    • I think the father is too ill to be honest. He’s in bed and probably couldn’t move abroad even if he got the permission.


      November 14, 2011 at 7:24 am

  2. Nice work Jessica, you are such an excellent writer!

    Matt S.

    November 14, 2011 at 5:13 am

  3. Wow, that seem like a good one. I haven’t even heard of it, but I am now going to search it out. Thanks Jessica. I love the line about Microwave ovens, did make me chuckle!!


    Scott Lawlor

    November 14, 2011 at 10:23 am

    • I think you’ll hear about it. It’s gotten a lot of buzz at the festivals. And who knows, maybe it will turn up as a candidate for best foreign movie was the Oscar time approaches? I don’t think it’s THAT good, but it’s certainly worth watching. It’s very naturalistic in the style, with an improvised feeling to it. I came to think of Mike Leigh for some reason.


      November 14, 2011 at 1:40 pm

  4. Very nice review, Jessica. It was also really fun to chat with you about this movie the other day. I really hadn’t gotten a chance to do that with anybody because so few have seen it. I was reminded just how much I loved the film.

    And interesting little tidbit for you. When I saw it at TIFF there were many Iranians in the audience, and after the film and Q&A, the director was standing outside the cinema and many of the Iranian audience members were going to him and giving him hugs. That kind of warmth and appreciation really got to me. This is clearly a film that speaks to people, particularly Iranians who want to see their home country get better.

    Corey Atad

    November 15, 2011 at 3:21 pm

    • Thank you! The pleasure was on my side. It really increses the joy you get from a movie if you have someone to talk to about it, doesn’t it? Unfortunately very few people have seen or even heard of this movie, so it’s a bit hard to find someone in this case. I’m glad to hear that he got such a nice reception at TIFF. I can definitely see the appeal it must have to Iranians in exile who have faced the same issues as the people in the movie.


      November 15, 2011 at 3:58 pm

  5. A Separation is Iran’s official entry to the Oscars, and based on the buzz, it could very easily be nominated. It’ll almost certainly make the short list. It’s interesting, though since I’d assume it has the support of the Iranian government if it’s their official entry (I don’t know how countries determine what their official entry is, actually – I should find that out), and it sounds like it definitely has some political subtext to it. I really wanted to see it when it played a festival here a couple of weeks ago, but it only played once and the scheduling was bad.

    If you’re interested in the Jafar Panahi case, his documentary This is Not a Film is quite excellent – and a film that would definitely be outside government approval (Panahi and his co-director, now also under arrest, smuggled the footage out of the country on a flash drive).


    November 17, 2011 at 5:27 pm

    • That is an interesting observation, that it’s nominated by Iran. I think there is a political subtext that is not in the favour of the current state of the country.

      I’d really like to see that Panahi case, especially after hearing about how it was smuggled out. I don’t know how to get access to it. Perhaps I can suggest it to my local movie club.


      November 17, 2011 at 10:28 pm

      • The film is playing the festival circuit now in North America (it just played the AFI Fest in Los Angeles, where I almost got to see A Separation as well, and it was at TIFF as well); I don’t know about elsewhere. Definitely worth tracking down if you can find it.

        Jandy Stone

        November 18, 2011 at 3:03 am

        • Haven’t seen anything about it here. I just checked up of they’re showing it at the ongoing Stockholm film festival but alas not. I’ll keep my eyes open for it.


          November 18, 2011 at 7:33 am

  6. […] A Separation – has made it into many top 10 lists of this year. For me it was an eye-opener about the situation in Iran and the difficulties that secularized intellectual face, giving them no option but to leave, separating from their country. […]

  7. […] Paradox Film Actually Never Too Early Movie Predictions Sketchy Details Surrender to the Void The Velvet Cafe Wide Screen […]

  8. […] Simin – en separation. Andra som har sett och gillat den är bl a Movies – Noir, Fiffi och Jessica. Så om inte jag har övertygat er så kan säkert mina bloggkollegor göra […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: