The Velvet Café

A room for thoughts about movies

Tap dancing was never lovelier

with 10 comments

Saturday night. My 17 year old is on her way out to see some friends, and pops into the living room to say goodbye.

She throws a glance at the TV screen and then she turns towards her parents. In her face I see disbelief mixed with pity and contempt. And I don’t think it’s referring to the bottle of wine we were sharing. It was our choice of movie.

I expect an “Are you serious?” or “Why don’t you get a life?” but instead she pulls up a video camera and starts to film us. For what purpose I’m not sure. Maybe I’ll find myself on YouTube as an example of the species Unusually Pathetic Parents.

Growing older
I can’t say I’m surprised at her lack of approval. I was never much into tap dancing either when I was young.

My memory may be blurred, but as far as I can recall, it was way more common to see it back in the days. The Swedish public television used to show a lot of “old movies” (that will say in black and white), especially in the weekends, and in those matinees it was perfectly normal for people to suddenly throw themselves into a dance- and song number. I just couldn’t get it.  They had put some smattering thing under their shoes and the stomped with their feet ridiculously fast, so what? I’d rather see them go on with the plot!

Something has happened over the years. Maybe it’s a part of the package of growing older. For years you find it incomprehensible how adults can eat such horrid things as olives. And then all of a sudden you find yourself happily munching on them without quite knowing how it happened. One day you wake up realizing that you now prefer beer to soda and that you’ve become addicted to coffee. And tap dancing isn’t the annoying break when nothing happens. On contrary: it can be the very reason for a movie to exist.

That is definitely the case with the movie that enchanted us this night, You Were Never Lovelier from 1942, starring Fred Astaire and Rita Hayworth. This is a romantic comedy with a rather thin, silly plot and flat characters, where the most original thing about it is that it takes place in Argentina. Completely forgettable at its best – quite annoying at its worst for the way it portrays women as mindless and obsessed with courting and getting married. And yet – it’s so old that you haven’t got any choice but to forgive it. Admittedly there were film makers around at that time that feel more modern today – Frank Capra being one of them. But there isn’t much point in judging old movies for being dated. They are what they are.

Divine dancing
If it only was for the plot, this would be a 2/5 rated movie at the most. However it’s not because of plots and acting that you watch Astaire and Hayworth. It’s because of the dancing. And the word that comes to my mind when I’m trying to describe it is “divine”. I’m really not prone to tossing around words like that (for instance I’m very sceptic to the word “masterpiece”), but there is something unearthly about the quality in those dancing numbers.

If the movie wasn’t so old you could almost have suspected them for playing tricks with us. But there’s no CGI involved in this. It’s all about practice. And I’m not talking about ordinary repetition, aiming for “good enough”. I’m talking about obsession, insanity, practicing that could go on for weeks to nail just a single dance number because nothing but perfection was acceptable. Will the world ever see anything like that again?

Fred Astaire is probably the most well known and loved dancing actors ever, only challenged by Gene Kelly. But what took me a little by surprise was how good Rita Hayworth was. She really matches Astaire in her dancing skills and what more – she’s radiant. Such a beauty! And I couldn’t help thinking: how strange isn’t it that such a gorgeous woman nowadays would be considered if not “fat”, at least slightly overweight, at least for an acting or model career, where you’re at an advantage if you look as if you’re suffering from a deadly disease?

Rita Hayworth. If you listen to me from your heaven: You were never lovelier! You made our Saturday night extraordinary. Even if I can’t convince my 17 year about it.

You Were Never Lovelier (William Seiter, US, 1942) My rating: The dancing: 5/5 The rest: 2/5

Written by Jessica

October 21, 2011 at 1:00 am

10 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. I am sorry Jessica, but just seeing that picture made me shake my head. You cannot be serious! It has nothing to do with age I can tell you, I am much older than you. And I still cannot stand those dancing films with Fred Astaire, perfection or not. You would have to tie me to a chair if you wanted me to sit through the full movie and I still could close my eyes. I am on the side of your 17 year old.

    Science Guru

    October 21, 2011 at 7:40 am

    • Pfft. Some of us just mature more slowly. One day you’ll wake up and you too will enjoy the beauty of a perfectly performed tap dance! 😉
      And besides, what are you talking about, closing your eyes? There are methods. Ever seen Clockwork Orange?


      October 21, 2011 at 7:50 am

  2. While I’m no fan of specifically tap dancing, I have to agree with you in gaining a whole new appreciation for these kinds of movies. I find it very interesting how imbibed I am with a feeling of nostalgia even though these movies were made decades before I was even born — cultural imperialisma at its best?


    October 21, 2011 at 9:59 am

    • Indeed. I don’t know if it’s nostalgia, but I find it refreshing and soothing at the same time to watch a movie void of cellphones and wwww once in a while.


      October 21, 2011 at 10:10 am

  3. HAHA I am not looking forward to my girls being embarrassed of me. Er, well actually I am. I am SO going to use it to my advantage hahah

    Brilliant write up, the dancing in those older films is truly amazing!!

    Thanks my friends

    Scott Lawlor

    October 21, 2011 at 10:33 am

    • Thank you Scott! To be honest I’m a little bit surprised at how much patience they have with me considering the level of my geekiness.


      October 21, 2011 at 11:04 am

  4. Simple story, light jokes, singing, dancing. What else do you need for a nice lovely movie. I do not believe liking this kind of movies have something to do with age. I would have enjoy it 5 years ago as much as I enjoy it today


    October 22, 2011 at 3:17 pm

    • Well, to be honest I would have enjoyed it as much five years ago, but not twentyfive years ago. I had little udnerstanding for tap dancing numbers when I was young. I thought they interrupted the plot. Nowadays I think differently and enjoy the shear joy they bring to me. It’s nonsense – but fun nonsense.


      October 22, 2011 at 8:55 pm

  5. […] Banana Oil Comparison Shopping: Little Women Submitted by: Banana Oil Site Name: The Velvet Cafe Tap dancing was never lovelier Submitted by: The Velvet Cafe Site Name: Online-Inquirer Taxi Driver: 35th Anniversary Edition […]

  6. […] Banana Oil Comparison Shopping: Little Women Submitted by: Banana Oil Site Name: The Velvet Cafe Tap dancing was never lovelier Submitted by: The Velvet Cafe Site Name: Online-Inquirer Taxi Driver: 35th Anniversary Edition […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: